SAP - Earnings, Competition & Business ByDesign
SAP - A Rethink Just Before Sapphire
For the last few weeks, I've heard unpleasant rumors about SAP. Because I don't spread rumors, I haven't helped the spread of same. However, the recent earnings report raised a number of concerns just prior to next week's SAPPHIRE conference.
This bombshell was in the investor documents provided to shareholders today:
"Small and Midsize Enterprises and SAP Business ByDesign
SAP’s small and midsize enterprise (SME) business continued to perform well in the first quarter of 2008 as the Company added more than 1,570 new SME customers (excluding customers from Business Objects) in the quarter, representing a 28% increase compared to the first quarter of 2007. A principal component of the SME strategy is SAP’s breakthrough innovative new solution, SAP Business ByDesign. Since last September’s announcement of SAP Business ByDesign, the Company has been working closely with early customers and partners to validate and fine-tune the solution. As a result of this process, SAP has elected to modify the rollout strategy for SAP Business ByDesign to ensure a more focused and controlled ramp-up process. The new rollout strategy includes the following:
- For 2008, go-to-market efforts for SAP Business ByDesign will focus on six countries, where all the current productive early customers are based and which represent a large amount of the worldwide volume market opportunity. Additional country rollouts will be executed in 2009.
- It is expected to take around 12 months to 18 months longer than the original 2010 target to reach the SAP Business ByDesign $1 billion revenue and 10,000 customer potential.
- However, the Company will use SAP Business ByDesign innovations and technologies for the existing solutions and this will contribute significantly to the overall revenues of SAP in 2010.
- Also, the Company will engage with significantly less than 1,000 customers in 2008.
In light of the modified rollout strategy, SAP will reduce its accelerated investments around SAP Business ByDesign in 2008 by approximately €100 million, which is expected to result in additional operating margin expansion in 2008 as noted in the “Business Outlook” section of this release. Furthermore, beginning in 2009 there will be no further accelerated investments. The expected expenses related to SAP Business ByDesign will be funded out of SAP’s normal operational business.
SAP maintains its full confidence in the product, the market opportunity and the associated business model of SAP Business ByDesign, as the Company continues to move toward volume readiness in 2008. " (Source: http://www.sap.com/about/investor/press.epx?pressID=9406)
SAP Business ByDesign has consistently been the most discussed product line within the Enterprise Irregulars whenever SAP products are discussed. Significant issues have been raised previously about:
- the channel program needed to sell this product. Was this channel economically attractive to providers?
- the ability to sell this product line. Do partners or SAP have the materials, collateral, training, etc. to effectively identify prospects and close deals? Can these be done profitably?
- the 50-100 customer per blade limitation
- the long-term strategy for the product. Would Business ByDesign become the future product platform for SAP? Would this eventually replace other product lines?
While Business ByDesign is a robust solution that SAP had consistently maintained would remain a SMB product, their announcement today would imply that parts of the solution may be utilized in other SAP products.
Behind these changes involving Business ByDesign are some hard economic facts:
- the effect of the falling dollar vis-a-vis the Euro has adversely affected SAP's earnings
- a review of their headcount showed that the company added a lot of positions in their North American operations. Specifically, the addition of Business Objects personnel has added materially to their ranks. Whether by design (no pun intended) or not, the company has grown the ranks of its Sales & Marketing, General & Administrative and Infrastructure headcount by 20-30%. (see attached graphic or follow link to full SAP presentation: http://www.sap.com/about/investor/reports/quarterlyreport/2008/pdf/Q1_2008_E_final2.pdf)
The added effect of more personnel, slower sales of Business ByDesign and other factors caused total revenue to go up 14% while operating expenses increased 22%.
Going into SAPPHIRE, SAP management should expect questions such as:
- Will SAP embark on layoffs, especially in North American non-client facing personnel?
- What progress has SAP made in developing its Business ByDesign channel program?
- Has SAP improved the economics for channel partners for its Business ByDesign product?
- Will SAP share with us details involving the technical difficulties they are examining in the Business ByDesign product line?
On balance, the bulk of the earnings announcement was positive but not surprising. The company posted continued growth and new customer gains. The company continued to gain market share. However, the difficulties with Business ByDesign should cause investors to question whether this company can effectively take the SMB space as confidently as they have pursued large enterprises.
For those who caught Marc Benioff and Hasso Plattner at the Churchill event, Marc teased Dr. Plattner about building SAP on the Force.com platform. Today, that might look like a better on-demand/SaaS strategy afterall.


